Overall the weekend went well. The weather started out terribly and Saturday morning at the outdoor martial arts promotion the temp was in the upper 50's/lower 60's and we were shivering under fog so moisture-laden it was spitting tiny droplets. But after a few hours, the sun burned through and the day turned beautiful--and we all got a little sunburned. Sigh. I mention these little incidences because weather is one of those things certain people always complain about when they come visit us, as if cold fog in summer is the result of our foolish home-buying decisions, and visible signs of too much sun is a poor reflection on my ability to make wise choices for the well-being of my children. But actually, MIL started out the weekend very well regulated, so that even the terrible weather and mild sunburns did not lead to painful conversations. In fact, MIL was very patient and gracious with everything on Saturday, and--interpersonally speaking--we had a lovely day, all day!
The three girls before the official event started.
Each new black belt is escorted down to the front by a higher-ranking belt.
Sunny was escorted by a young man who also leads classes, and is one of her favorite instructors.
Receiving the new belt from Master Jin, the man who brought Ho Kuk Mu Sul (Korean Mixed Martial Arts) to the States.
Congratulations to the new first degree black belts!
Sunny with her two favorite instructors.
Sunny did well with her part in the black belt demonstrations, performing her sword form and leaping off of other people to break boards with kicks. Tough little girls are so cute, and we are very proud of her. Merry is one step behind her older sister, and will likely earn her black belt at the Winter promotions. And then Happy is already one step behind that, so will earn hers sometime in the next couple of years. Smiley will start martial arts sometime this next year, since he will be in kindergarten! I can't believe it--my little guy getting so big.
random cute photo of Smiley, since we did not get any of him this past weekend. This was taken at Easter up at my in-laws'
So that was Saturday. Sunday we went to church and it was another gorgeous day, so afterwards we went out to a restaurant on the Santa Cruz wharf and then lounged on the beach for a few minutes and then headed the scenic route home, driving as much as possible along the coast to enjoy the ocean views. But by the time we arrived back home, when most of the afternoon was gone, MIL was starting to lose her patience. You see, she is always conflicted when they visit us--in her mind, how can we "goof off" when there is so much work needing to be done around our house and property? So what we see as positive, good and even necessary family relaxation time, she sees as a waste of time. And that starts to make her anxious, and then negative. So MIL was a trooper on Saturday, not complaining about how we were "wasting" time, even when we lingered after the promotion event was over to play at the playground and explore a nearby creek. But then Sunday, after we had "wasted" that whole day too, it was just too much, and after dinner when the kids were in bed and the grownups were chatting in the living room, things got negative.
I can really understand MIL's frustration. DH and I bought this little
Ok, rant over. But I'm sure you can imagine how frustration and financial limitations could lead to despondency, and then to apathy, which is where I think my Dear Husband has remained for several years now. We started out well after buying the house, but there was so much to do, and then that good home-improvement momentum failed, and now it has been quite a while since DH's parents have seen any real improvements to the property, and pretty much anywhere you look around the house and yard there are numerous half-completed projects, problems and eyesores begging for attention, which we seem to have just forgotten about or have resigned ourselves to live with as-is. Like the falling-over front fence. The gaping hole around the fireplace where the soapstone surround will be someday. The cracked bathroom sink without a working "cold" tap. The shoplight clamped to a curtain rod in the bedroom in lieu of a hardwired fixture. These things we have been fine living with on temporary basis--but when temporary becomes seemingly permanent. . . it is really easy to understand why MIL has a hard time visiting without becoming upset by her surroundings. She and FIL are can-do, hands-on people, and let me tell you, it is just about killing her that she can't do what she wants with us, and with our space, when she so desperately feels she and FIL can't keep their hands off our projects, if any of them will ever get done.
But what she forgets is that they are our projects. And that whatever her feelings are, and however strong her desire for resolution, they actually don't matter. She is psychologically investing herself into things that are not really her concern, and over which she really has no control. But she has a hard time separating herself, because of course she wants the best for her kids and grandkids--which would be the opposite of what this house is--and because she believes that she and FIL are the only ones who can make the positive changes the house needs.
OK, now this is fascinating for me to be writing, because none of this is what I set out to write. I was not going to talk about our house and projects at all, but instead the interpersonal aspects of the visit and what God is showing me through them. But I have just realized that so much of what I just said about MIL directly translates to where I was really going. Let's see if I can make these connections the least bit coherent. . . .
The bottom line is that we had some really good things happening interpersonally this weekend, but also some returning to old ways of relating, and old stresses. And my MIL did a good job of letting go of some things, and being patient, and overlooking a lot. . . but then could only go so far. Still, good for her, and thank you God!
I think this might be the first weekend where I want to give MIL more credit for keeping the peace than I give myself. While she did a good job Saturday of letting go of a lot, I had a harder time. As you might have guessed from my last post before the weekend, I was doing my best to have a good attitude and expect the best of our time with family--and yet was fearful of the less-than-best. I confess that I was anticipating negativity, and so when it did come, even if briefly, I let myself catch and dwell on it, which of course just made me all the more vulnerable to the next little bit of negativity. In other words, I was dwelling in a too-weak heart place, and ended up being part of the problem and not the solution. I can't be too hard on myself about this, as I know I have a bit of PTSD lingering from the worst years of our relationship and it makes me prone to fear and self-protectiveness, but I'm still disappointed. I know in my head that God is the only One who can actually make things good, who will release me from fear, who will protect me and fill me with all the strength and love I need at any moment to do the hard work of loving fully--but I too easily slip back into that place of interpersonal cowering, distrusting, hiding.
Must remind myself--and that is ok too. His strength is made perfect in my weakness. And when I see how my own self-protective instincts don't actually help or heal anything, I realize all the more how much I need Him.
So there were a couple of moments Saturday that I allowed little bits of negativity to get to me, and I ended up disheartened and momentarily very upset, even if overall the day went well. At the time I just tried to pretend on the outside that all was fine, but inside I was in quite a storm. The one incident I will share with you--because it was the catalyst for God speaking to me--was really quite silly. For the potluck after the black belt promotions, I had brought our own dishware, utensils, napkins and cups. It just seemed wise, since there would be a chance that those assigned to bring such things would not bring enough, and I am also moving our family as much as possible towards consuming less plastic, especially single-use plastic like disposable forks and cups. Well, everyone accepted the plates and cutlery I handed out without comment, but when it came to the cup, well, MIL just put her foot down. She had no reason to refuse, since I had plenty of cups for everyone, and would have to wash her unused cup anyway when we got home just because it had been carried with the dirty things on the way home. But she actually turned down the clean cup I was holding out for her, and instead went and got a disposable cup provided by someone else, a cup that then would just go in the trash. I know she was just taking a stance against what she thinks is an extreme, insidious, liberal Environmentalism that poses as Good Stewardship. But let's admit, it was also purposefully taking a stance against me personally. It felt like an insult, like a rejection, just so illogical and purposeful that it made me boil.
That was the last in a series of small negative flare-ups that morning, and was like the straw that broke the camel's back. I tried not to show my annoyance, but I am sure MIL was watching for it, and likely picked up a hint. Those of you who know me IRL will agree that I am pretty much an open book. So maybe she felt she needed that small victory over me, I don't know--and maybe it helped her be more regulated and gracious the rest of the day. All I know is that at that moment it made me so indignant I had a hard time getting over it. But after we left the picnic area and were loading things into the car, I spewed a little of my hurt and anger to my Dear Husband--and as I spoke, I realized the Holy Spirit was nudging me to listen to myself. And as I did so, I realized I was internalizing my MIL's choice and making it all about me. Talk about narcissism--and self-defeating foolishness. Why did MIL's choice to use the disposable cup have anything to do with me? I was somehow allowing it to define me, when of course the only person it says anything about is MIL.
Ahhhh, this seems so simple, and yet seems to be such a struggle for me, and in an instant I knew this was key to another struggle I've been asking God for insight into--my parenting. The two interpersonal issues are intertwined, and now I just need to understand in fullness how, to then better resolve both issues.
The revelation is two-fold:
a) I am too thinned-skinned, so I take in and make part of me whatever negativity I encounter. I absorb rather than deflect.
b) I react rather than respond to interpersonal conflict. This means I have strong knee-jerk reactions to negativity, quite possibly from a self-protective instinct.
You can see how those two things are related--how they stem from the same place in me, and how they would apply to all kinds of interpersonal relationships. My parents will be nodding at the first one--my Mother is not one to criticize her children, but she has always told me that I am too sensitive, since I was a kid. And I have known the second one for a couple of year now in regards to my parenting--but knowing a truth about myself is different than understanding it's full ramifications, and knowing what to do about it. But I have never before considered how the two are connected--and now with this revelation I feel I am that much closer to freedom from the tyranny of the negative in these two facets of my life!
Let me just remind everyone reading this--my kids are healthy, normal kids. Likely much better behaved than many. So what I have struggled with in my parenting of them is not what they do wrong, but how much of a hard time I have responding to it with grace instead of legalism (b), and how hard it is for me not to take their "failures" to heart as a sign of how I am failing them as a mother (a).
And now here is where the processing comes around to MIL and her unhappiness with our house, and how she is allowing herself to suffer psychologically from her lack of control over us and our house, and how our relationship suffers from her desire for complete control over us and our house. Just swap out "me" for "MIL" and "my children and their choices" for "us and our house" and you can clearly see the parallel.
This is not the first time I have realized just how similar my MIL and I are.
Neither is it the first time I have learned something about myself or my parenting from my relationship with my MIL.
*Now looking over what I've written I wonder--do both a) and b) apply to my MIL as well? Are these the same things she is doing?! Are her verbal lashings-out her own self-protective attempts to deflect what she feels is a painful challenge to her own Selfhood?
I am just so thankful that God keeps whispering to me, that He keeps giving me ears to hear and eyes to see. I hope He will continue to grow and shape me to be the daughter-in-law and parent that He wants me to be.
But now. . . I am still processing those two important ideas. Since they are still new, I don't really know the fullness of how they are connected and what they ultimately mean. But I see that understanding whatever is at the heart of those two issues will be the key to building better and stronger relationships with my children and my MIL. And probably my Dear Husband too! I have an inkling that the ideas are related to my earlier ponderings on the idea of my identity as Blessed, as a creature defined solely by who I am in Jesus. . . but I don't have the time or brainpower to go there yet. I need to let the first ideas settle into me, and figure out what to do with them--then I can delve further.
So there you have it--my imperfectly reasoned, but hopefully clearly-enough articulated thoughts for this week. I would love to hear your thoughts, if you see some connection I have not yet mentioned, or if you have experience with any of these concepts from your own life!
And in the meantime, I hope you all have long and love-filled weekends, however you will be spending them.
You and I are very much alike, so I can completely relate to a lot of what you are writing here. I feel like I internalize criticism the same way you do and often think that people's choices (like the one to use the cup) are intentionally meant to criticize my own choices. I am thankful for my husband who is usually able to help me see it's not always about me when I get upset.
ReplyDeleteBut just as you may be feeling like you're struggling with making things about you that have nothing to do with you, your MIL is doing the same thing. The house projects have nothing to do with her, yet somehow she is making it about her and projecting that onto your family.
I don't know your MIL at all, but from what I have read on here about your relationship it seems to me that you and she are a lot more alike than you may think you are. And I mean that is a good way - not that you are any of the negative things that you have said here about her (and not that you say a lot of negative things either). It's more that the things that bother you about your MIL may be things that you are struggling with yourself - things the Holy Spirit is urging you to look at. I have found that the people in my life that I have the most conflict with tend to be people that exhibit characteristics that annoy me about myself.
That may not be the case at all with you and your MIL, but it's just something I've noticed about myself. Please don't think that I am criticizing you at all by comparing you to her. You know (hopefully) how much I adore you and think you are a wonderful person.
As far as the home renovations go - if you guys are thriving and comfortable, I wouldn't even worry about it. I'm a function over form person, which is why I haven't done any of the renovations to my house that I set out to do eight years ago. I still have patches on my walls that need painted over from work that was done by a contractor over two years ago. That stuff just doesn't bother me, as I assume it doesn't bother you. It's too bad your MIL can't see and appreciate your priorities - money for great activities like the martial arts she just experienced are more important that windows and getting to spend time with loved ones on a weekend visit is more important than doing work around your house.
It's a shame that there are so many loopholes to jump through just to put in a stupid window. You would think the government would want to encourage the energy efficiency of new windows, not discourage people through cost. Ugh.
Lastly, the kids look adorable in their gis. And I can't believe how big Smiley is getting! I'm thinking about putting David in some marital arts this fall and it's good to hear that as an experienced martial arts mom you think that is a good age to start.
I hope you're having a wonderful weekend!
Ugh Control…I know I try to control my kids and I wondering how that natural control bond breaks…clearly it never broke with your MIL. I know I have to make a conscious effort at times to not control my kids - so far they are small things…clothing, timing of tasks when it really doesn't matter even though I have a preference of when those tasks happen!
ReplyDeleteAs far as your house - I am glad your perspective is fully thought out and reasons because I agree completely with your stance. I mean - who cars if you have a clip on light instead of a fixture…does it work for you and your family…then you'll change it when it ups itself on the priority list. We tend to do house upgrades when things are falling apart. Our bathroom sink has big chunks of porcelain falling off and leaving large rusty spots…however…only Luke and I use that bathroom and we can live with it for now because we had to replace a kitchen that had cabinets with holes and shelves falling down. I don't think your house stuff is that out of the norm…just has a bigger focus on it. Your kitchen is the heart of your home and you put effort in it and made it "you" and made it lovely!
We are so hard on ourselves sometimes…I know I am terribly hard on myself and if I had someone close to me criticising me all the time I don't know if I could handle it with the grace you do. For the record - your house is cozy and comfortable with and beautiful locale and your children and bright funny engaging people whose company I enjoy…and I can't say that abouta lot of the spoiled uninterested in talking to adults children I know. You are a fabulous mom and friend and I love you!
Thank you for the encouraging words, Jessica, and not being afraid to challenge my thinking with the comparison between me and my MIL. Yes, I completely agree. I have thought this before in the past, but usually on values, personality, etc.--this was really the first time I wondered if all my same heart issues are similar too.
ReplyDeleteI am so glad our girls have been in martial arts (I consider it their "P.E"), and think it is good for kids--depending upon the school and instructors. I know of a couple of schools in the area that seem too dogmatic, or harsh with the kids, or try to infuse meditation/Eastern religion into their practice of the martial arts--all fine for other families, but I would not be comfortable with those dynamics. This school teaches discipline and respect and expects each child to be leading others (like helping the lower belts learn--even adults) and overall the values are exactly what I would want for our kids. : ) I hope you find a school you like for your kids!
Susan, thank you so much for the big verbal hug! I am so thankful for your love! Yes, I am really trying to walk that fine line in my parenting of giving them whatever responsibility they can handle, and trying to encourage them to make choices on their own, and still wanting to make sure I get the outcome I feel they/we need. It's so hard, because especially as a homeschool mom I need a certain amount of control over my kids--or we would never get stuff done! But Control in the bigger picture--that's where I really need to let. go. and allow God to claim responsibility for my children's spirits and not worry so much about how they will "turn out." What I see as character flaws--that is where I find myself being legalistic and trying to control (force) the desired outcome. Again--it's from fear and insecurity, and so cannot be good.
ReplyDeleteBut still--thank you for being so sweet with your "words of affirmation" ; ) Even with my flaws I do know I am a good enough mom--my kids are happy and well cared-for and seem to be turning out well despite me. ; )
I'm so glad you have seen my little house so you know what all I'm talking about! Thank you for being so sweet about that too. I like my little decrepit house, and think that heart-peace in the midst of so much I too could be upset over is also a complete gift from God. And I always have to laugh at how clear of a metaphor this little house is for our messy and imperfect but simple and safe and cozy family life! (And for my own blogging!) No glossing over with drywall and paint--no, you see the bare bones of who we are, and turns out that's not all bad. : )